Proofs of Imamate of Ahl al-Bayt. Quran, Hadith, and Infallibility

Proofs Confirming the Imamate of Ahl Al-bayt (AS)

Texts quoted from the Messenger of Allah referring to the Imamate, after his demise, of the nation`s Ahl al-Bayt (AS) are numerous; here are the most famous among them:
According to Muslim`s Sahih, relying on isnad which goes back to Zaid ibn Arqam, the Messenger of Allah , so Zaid narrated, said, “O people! I am a human upon whom the messenger of my Lord is about to call. I will surrender to the call, and I am leaving among you two weighty things: the first of them is the Book of Allah wherein there is guidance and noor. So, take the Book of Allah, for in it there is guidance and there is noor. Uphold the Book of Allah and adhere to it. And (the other are) my Ahl al-Bayt (AS). I commend to you, in the Name of Allah, my Ahl al-Bayt (AS);I commend to you, in the Name of Allah, my Ahl al-Bayt (AS); I commend to you, in the Name of Allah, my Ahl al-Bayt (AS).”[2] In al-Tirmidhi`s Sahih, through isnad traced to Jābir ibn Abdullah [al-Ansāri], the latter said, “I saw the Messenger of Allah on the Day of `Arafa when he performed his [last] pilgrimage. He was riding his she-camel Qaswa. He delivered a sermon, and I heard him saying, `O people! I have left among you that, so long as you uphold to it, you shall never stray: The Book of Allah and my `itrah, my Ahl al-Bayt`.”[3]
Had there been only this hadīth, it would have sufficed to prove the authenticity of the Shī`ah sect which obligates clinging to Ahl al-Bayt (AS) in addition to clinging to the Glorious Book of Allah. We find in this hadīth the order of the Messenger of Allah , as clearly as can be, that we should uphold Ahl al-Bayt (AS) after his demise, and that such upholding, in addition to adhering to the Glorious Qur`ān, is the condition for one`s salvation versus straying.
Although Muslim and many other scholars of hadīth from among the Sunnis have included this hadīth in their Sahih and musnad books, it is to my great amazement that I find most Sunnis not familiar with it. They deny it when they hear about it, as if it does not exist, saying that what is accurate in this regard is what Abū Hurayrah had said, that is, the Messenger of Allah said, “I have left among you two things that will never let you stray so long as you adhere to them or act upon them: the Book of Allah and my Sunnah.”[4] Having investigated the source of this tradition, I found out that it was not recorded in any of the Sahih books. Al-Bukhāri, al-Nisā`i, al-Dhahabi and others have labelled it as “weak”[5]. It is narrated by al-Hakim in his Mustadrak which, according to the consensus of Sunni scholars, is regarded as being less [in prestige] than the Sahih book of Muslim who stated it in this wording: “...the Book of Allah and my `itrah, my Ahl al-Bayt (AS).”
Even if we suppose there is no difference between both narratives, we have to surrender to the fact that what is meant by the phrase “my Sunnah”, as it exists in al-Hakim`s narrative, is the Sunnah derived from the venue of the Household of the Prophet , not from that of others, as is quite obvious in Muslim`s narrative. As for sticking to the narrative of al-Hakim wherein he says, “... the Book of Allah and my Sunnah,” rejecting Muslim`s version of “... the Book of Allah and my `itrah, my Ahl al-Bayt (AS),” this goes against not only the consensus of the Sunni scholars of hadīth, who all regard the traditions narrated by Muslim with higher regards than those narrated by al-Hakim, it is also contrary to logic and reason because the word “Sunnah” by itself as narrated by al-Hakim does not convey a specific meaning, since all Islamic sects claim they follow the Sunnah of the Prophet . Moreover, there are many differences among these sects, and the reasons behind such differences are rendered to the differences in how the Prophet`s Sunnah was transmitted to them, i.e. through various venues, the Sunnah which explains and complements the Holy Qur`ān, the Sunnah the accuracy of which is agreed upon by all Islamic sects. Hence, the differences in the transmitted hadīth led also to differences in interpreting the Qur`ān. The Sunnah of the Prophet , therefore, became many Sunnahs and the Muslims, accordingly, split into sects and groups which are said to number thirty-seven. So, which of these Sunnahs is more worthy of being followed? This question comes naturally to the mind of anyone who deeply discerns such differences. The above-quoted hadīth came to respond to such differences so that the Muslims would not be left puzzled with regard to their Islamic faith following the departure from this world of the one who convey it to them. This is why there have been sacred instructions by the Prophet mandating that the purified Sunnah of he Prophet must be derived from the venue of the Ahl al-Bayt (AS) of the Prophet , those who are described by the Qur`ān as tāhir, Purified, a description which is quite clear and accepts no other meaning. Such a derivation, and only such a derivation, brings security against dissension and straying.
In his Sahih, relying on the isnad of Safiyya daughter of Shaybah, Muslim quotes the latter saying that `Ā`isha said, “The Messenger of Allah came out wearing an unsown garment of black [camel] hair. He brought al-Hasan ibn Ali (AS) and let him in. Then al-Husayn (AS) came and he let him, too, in. Then Fātima (AS) came in and he let her, too, in. Then Ali (AS) came. He let him, too. Then he said [i.e. quoted the following verse], `Surely Allah wishes to remove all abomination from you, O People of the House [of the Prophet] and to purify you with a perfect purification` (Qur`ān, 33:33).”[6] Also in Muslim`s Sahih we read the following: “When this verse was revealed: `Say: Come! Let us gather together our sons and your sons, our women and your women, ourselves and yourselves, then let us earnestly pray and invoke Allah`s curse on the liars` (Qur`ān, 3:61), the Messenger of Allah called upon Ali (AS), Fātima (AS), al-Hasan (AS) and al-Husayn (AS) then said, `Lord! These are my Ahl al-Bayt`.”[7] From both of these traditions, it is quite clear that Ahl al-Bayt (AS), during the lifetime of the Prophet , were: Ali (AS), Fātima (AS) and both their sons (AS).

But What About the Wives of the Prophet ?

In his Sahih, Muslim quotes Zaid ibn Arqam citing the Prophet saying, “I am leaving with you two weighty things: one of them is the Book of Allah, the most Exalted, the most Great, and it is the Rope of Allah; whoever adheres to it is guided and whoever abandons it strays.” In the same tradition, people inquired whether his Ahl al-Bayt (AS) included his wives. “No,” said he, “By Allah! A woman remains with the man for a period of time, then he may divorce her, whereupon she returns to her father and people. His Ahl al-Bayt (AS) come from his loins, his nearest in kin who are prohibited from taking charity after his demise.”[8]
To quote al-Tirmidhi`s Sahih, where the compiler relies on the authority of `Amr ibn Abū Salamah, who was raised by the Prophet , `Amr said, “When this verse was revealed: `Surely Allah wishes to remove all abomination from you, O People of the House [of the Prophet] and to purify you with a perfect purification` (Qur`ān, 33:33)` at the house of Umm Salamah, the Prophet called upon Fātima (AS), Hasan (AS) and Husayn (AS). He put a garment over them while Ali (AS) was behind him. He placed the garment over them all then supplicated thus: `Lord! These are my Ahl al-Bayt (AS); so, do remove abomination from them and purify them with a perfect purification.` Umm Salamah asked him, `May I be included with them, O Prophet of Allah?` He said, `Stay where you are, and you are in goodness.`”[9]
In his Musnad, [imām] Ahmad [ibn Hanbal] quotes Umm Salamah saying, “The Messenger of Allah said to Fātima (AS): `Bring me your husband and both sons.` She brought them in. He put a garment made in Fadak then put his hand on them and said, `Lord! These are the Progeny of Muhammad; so, let Your salutations and blessings be upon Muhammad and the Progeny of Muhammad; surely You are the Praised One, the most Glorified.` I lifted the garment in order to join them, but he pulled it from my hand and said, `You are in goodness.`”[10]
Despite the clarity of the previous proofs in identifying who Ahl al-Bayt (AS) are, some people oppose it and base their argument on the following verses from Surah al-Ahzab (Chapter 33 of the Holy Qur`ān), claiming that the term “Ahl al-Bayt (AS)” includes the wives of the Prophet :
O Prophet! Say to your consorts: “If you desire the life of this world, and its glitter, then come! I will provide for your enjoyment and set you free in a handsome manner. But if you seek Allah and His Prophet, and the abode of the hereafter, truly Allah has prepared a great reward for the well-doers from among you.” O consorts of the Prophet! If any of you were guilty of evident unseemly conduct, the punishment would be doubled to her, and that is easy for Allah. But any of you who is devout in the service of Allah and His Prophet, and does righteous deeds, to her We shall grant a reward twice as much and We have prepared a generous sustenance for her. O consorts of the Prophet! You are not like any (other) women: If you fear (Allah), do not be too complaisant of speech, lest one in whose heart there is a disease should be moved with desire: But speak a speech (that is) just. And stay in your houses, do not make a dazzling display, like that in the former times of ignorance, establish regular prayer and give regular charity, and obey Allah and His Prophet. And Allah only wishes to remove all abomination from you, you members of the family, and to make you pure and spotless.
Qur`ān, 33:28-33
As is quite clear, the argument of those who say that “Ahl al-Bayt (AS)” is a term which includes the wives of the Prophet is based on “... And Allah only wishes to remove all abomination from you, you members of the family, and to make you pure and spotless” falling in the same verse a portion of which deals with the wives of the Prophet .
This claim can be refuted from many angles; here are some of them:
1. The revelation of Qur`ānic verses in reference to threatening the wives of the Prophet that they could be divorced followed by the Will of Allah to purify Ahl al-Bayt (AS) with a perfect purification does not necessarily mean that on both occasions, the wives of the Prophet are implied simply because there are many verses in the Holy Qur`ān of this sort containing two different issues. The reason why they both fall in the same verse is perhaps due to their coincidently took place at the same time. One such an example is derived from these verses: “Forbidden to you (for food) are: dead meat, blood, the flesh of swine and that on which a name other than that of Allah has been invoked, that which has been killed by strangling, or by a violent blow, or by a headlong fall, or by being gored to death, that which has been (partly) eaten by a wild animal, unless you are able to slaughter it (in due way), that which is sacrificed on stone (altars). The division (of meat) by raffling with arrows is also (forbidden): That is impiety. This Day those who reject faith have given up all hope of your religion: Yet do not fear them, but fear Me. This Day I have perfected your religion for you, completed My favor upon you, and have chosen Islam for you as your religion” (Qur`ān, 5:3). You find in this verse how the subject revolving round the perfecting of the creed falls in the middle of the subject dealing with prohibitive foods!
2. What underscores the fact that the wives of the Prophet are not included in the meaning of this verse is that the subject relevant to the wives of the Prophet came in an Arabic pronoun specifically relevant to a group of females, whereas when the topic shifted to the purification of Ahl al-Bayt (AS), the pronoun changed to one relevant to a group of males.
3. The previously quoted authentic traditions recorded in the Sahih books of both Muslim and al-Tirmidhi, as well as in Ahmad`s Musnad and in others all prove unequivocally that the wives of the Prophet are not included among Ahl al-Bayt (AS). When Umm Salamah, may Allah be pleased with her, asked the Prophet , “May I be included with them, O Prophet of Allah?,” He said to her, “Stay where you are, and you are in goodness.” In Muslim`s narrative, people inquired whether his wives were among his Ahl al-Bayt (AS), and the answer came in the negative.
4. In the tradition of the two weighty things which Muslim, Ahmad and others narrate, the Prophet is cited as having said, “O people! I am leaving among you two things which, so long as you uphold them [both simultaneously], you shall never stray: the Book of Allah and my `itra, my Ahl al-Bayt,” it is quite clear that they have to be followed [with regard to all religious and secular issues]. If we suppose, just for the sake of debating, that the wives of the Prophet are the ones meant, or implied, in this tradition, in what way will the Muslims uphold them after the demise of the Messenger of Allah , bearing in mind that they were obligated to remain in their homes? How would one answer this question, knowing that they all lived in one and the same century? If one says that upholding them means citing the traditions from them, we would respond by saying that among them are those who did not narrate one single tradition!
The “abomination” [rijs] which occurs in the verse saying, ““... And Allah only wishes to remove all abomination from you, you members of the family, and to make you pure and spotless” means linguistically something filthy: a reference to sinning, while taharah (cleansiness) linguistically connotes piety. The meaning of the will of the Almighty, Praised and Glorified is He, to remove abomination from them, is to clear them of any sin and to raise their status above committing anything which points out to shortcomings in them. A sin, no matter how minor, is indicative of a flaw in the person who commits it. This means that Allah Almighty wanted to purify Ahl al-Bayt (AS) from committing any sin, minor or major, and this is nothing but a proof of Infallibility and, hence, purification.
As regarding what is said that the meaning of “purification” in this verse is merely an indication of religious piety, that is, their own avoidance of committing what Allah has prohibited them from committing while acting upon His Commandments, this claim is rejected because “purification” in such a sense is not relevant only to Ahl al-Bayt (AS) but to all Muslims. The Muslims are all obligated to act upon the injunctions of their creed: “Allah does not desire to put any hardship on you but to purify you, and so that He may complete His favor on you, perhaps you will be grateful” (Qur`ān, 5:6). Thus, if we agree that those regarding whom this verse was revealed are infallible, we will find out that the wives of the Prophet are not among them because they are not infallible, let alone the fact that nobody, be he from the early generations or from the latter ones, made such a claim, knowing fully well that the Prophet threatened to divorce them and made other threats against some of them as you will see in a chapter to come.

Additional Proofs for the Infallibility of Ahl Al-Bayt (AS)

1. Hadith al-Thaqalayn: Text of the tradition of the two weighty things: “O people! I am leaving among you two things which, so long as you uphold to them [both simultaneously], you shall never stray: the Book of Allah and my `itra, my Ahl al-Bayt (AS),” where there is a directive from the Prophet that the condition for not straying is upholding the Book of Allah and his `itra, Progeny. It is not rational for anyone who believes there is a possibility that there is something wrong, or any crookedness, in it can expect it to be a safe haven against straying. This proves the Infallibility of both weighty things: the Book of Allah, i.e. the greater weight which no falsehood can approach from front or back, and Ahl al-Bayt (AS), the great weight.
2. This Qur`ānic Verse: “And remember that Abraham was tried by his Lord with certain commands which he fulfilled. He said, `I will make you an Imām (guide) to the nations.` He pleaded: `What about my offspring?!` He answered, `My promise is not within the reach of evil-doers`” (Qur`ān, 2:124). Besides pointing out to the lofty status of Imamate, this verse also indicates that the “promise” of Allah, that is, Imamate, cannot be the lot of an oppressor. A sin, minor or major, renders one who commits it an oppressor. Hence, an Imām has to be divinely protected from committing any sin or wrongdoing.
3. Evidence in Mustadrak al-Sahihayn: Relying on the isnad of Hanash al-Kinani, al-Hakim cites the man saying that he heard Abu Dharr saying the following as he was holding to the door of he Ka`ba: “O people! Whoever knows me, I am who I am, and whoever does not, I am Abu Dharr. I heard the Messenger of Allah saying, `The similitude of my Ahl al-Bayt (AS) among you is like the ark of Noah: whoever boards it is safe [from drowning], and who ever lags behind it is drowned.”[11] al-Hakim adds saying that the isnad of this tradition is authentic.
4. Also in Mustadrak al-Sahihayn: Through the isnad traced to Ibn `Abbās, the same reference cites Ibn `Abbās quoting the Messenger of Allah saying, “The stars offer security for the people of the earth against drowning, while my Ahl al-Bayt (AS) are the security of my nation against dissension. If a tribe from among the Arabs opposes them, it will become the party of Iblis.”[12]
5. In al-Bukhāri`s Sahih: In order to further clarify the lofty status with which Ahl al-Bayt (AS) were blessed, we would like to quote some traditions narrated in al-Bukhāri`s Sahih and which address Ahl al-Bayt (AS) with “alayhim al-salam” (peace be upon them). They, rather than anyone else from among all the sahabah or the wives of the Prophet , were thus addressed. Following are examples narrated by al-Bukhāri in his Sahih:
Ali (AS) has said, “I used to have an established portion of the war booties, and the Prophet gave me an established portion of the khums. When I was going to have a daughter by Fātima (AS), peace be upon her, daughter of the Messenger of Allah ..., etc.”[13]
Al-Bukhāri also wrote saying, “... and the Prophet knocked at the door of Fātima (AS) and Ali (AS), peace be upon both of them, on a night for the prayers..., etc.”[14]
In another narration, the following is stated: “... He said, `I saw the Prophet , and al-Hasan (AS) son of Ali (AS), peace be upon both of them, looked like him..., etc.`”[15]
Also, the following is stated in the same reference: “... from Ali (AS) son of al-Husayn (AS), peace be upon both of them, he told him..., etc.”[16]
One may argue saying that this does not prove their distinction, but the question will then be, “Why then were they, rather than anyone else, thus greeted?”
6. Evidence From Hadīth: The Messenger of Allah has ordered anyone who blesses him to also bless his Progeny concurrently. In a tradition recorded by al-Bukhāri in his Sahih, relying on the isnad of Abd al-Rahman ibn Abi Layla, it is recorded that “... He said, `Ka`b ibn `Ajrah met me and said, `Grant me a gift!` The Prophet came out to see us, so we said to him, `O Messenger of Allah! We have already come to know how to greet you, but how should we bless you?` He said, `You should say: O Allah! Bless Muhammad and the Progeny of Muhammad as You blessed Ibrahim and the progeny of Ibrahim; surely You are the oft-Praised, the oft-Glorified`.”[17] The point of connection in this tradition between our master Ibrahim, peace be upon him and upon his progeny, on one hand, and our master Muhammad and his Progeny on the other is that Ibrahim, peace be upon him, was also a prophet, and his offspring were prophets to whom people referred after his demise. Likewise, the offspring of Muhammad were the custodians of the Message brought by Muhammad . The Muslims were ordered to refer to them after the demise of the Chosen One except they were Imāms (AS), not prophets, as was the case with the progeny of Ibrahim. In a dialogue between the Prophet and Ali (AS), the Prophet said, “Are you not pleased that your status with me is like that of Aaron to Moses except there is no prophet after me?”[18] We will later discuss this tradition.
It is concluded from all the above that Allah, the most Sublime and the most Great, specifically granted purification and Infallibility to Ahl al-Bayt (AS) in their capacity as the ones to fill the vacuum left by the Messenger of Allah with regard to transmitting the Message to future generations, to safeguard it from those who distort or cast doubt about it. What is the benefit of the Messenger of Allah conveying the Divine Sharī`a if it is not safeguarded after his death by trustworthy persons? What happened to past creeds suffices to answer this question. The followers of the latter creeds used to derive their legislation from any source after the departure from this world of those who conveyed such creeds to them. This is why distortion afflicted them as the most Great and the most Exalted One has said: “Can you (O men of faith